Home » Oops, your automotive has no insurance coverage

Oops, your automotive has no insurance coverage

The Monetary Companies Conduct Authority (FSCA) has warned Constantia Insurance coverage purchasers that their short-term insurance coverage insurance policies have lastly lapsed – and so they haven’t any automotive insurance coverage as of 1 October 2022.

In a press release on Monday, the FSCA warned that Constantia Insurance coverage purchasers might want to safe cowl with new insurers with impact from 1 October 2022. “The FSCA recognises that this will likely not present brokers with enough time to contact all impacted policyholders to offer them choices for appropriate various cowl.

“The FSCA strongly encourages CICL (Constantia Insurance coverage Firm Restricted) policyholders to urgently contact their brokers or monetary advisers for future protection choices to make sure uninterrupted insurance coverage cowl,” says the monetary authority.

In truth, purchasers have had just a few months’ value of warning that it might be sensible to search for new insurance coverage. Constantia Insurance coverage was positioned underneath provisional curatorship in direction of the top of June 2022, following a number of warnings by authorities that the corporate lacked the capital wanted to make sure it may proceed to function.

Finest try

At first, curator Ashish Desai appeared optimistic that the corporate would possibly survive. In a letter to the Reserve Financial institution’s Prudential Authority on 18 August, the curator wrote: “Upon assuming workplace, I motivated to the authority to not droop the [licence] of the corporate by way of part 27 of the Insurance coverage Act, and I indicated in conferences with the authority (on and round 27 July 2022) that I thought-about it necessary to obtain permission from the authority to difficulty new insurance policies with a purpose to have an inexpensive prospect of conserving the enterprise in accordance with the court docket order.

“My motivations on this respect had been set out in my letter to the authority, dated 29 July 2022. My motivations had been made on the premise of the understood place of the corporate and the enterprise as set out within the founding affidavit that was filed within the authority’s software for the court docket order.

“I’ve taken management of, managed and investigated the enterprise and operations of CICL, along with all belongings and pursuits referring to such enterprise, topic to the management of the Prudential Authority. I’ve constantly given consideration to the perfect pursuits of the corporate’s policyholders (in accordance with the court docket order); I’ve exercised the powers vested in me with a view to conserving the enterprise; I’ve – as much as the date of this letter – made funds of policyholders’ claims topic to the accessible sources of the corporate; (and) I’ve furnished the authority with progress stories on a weekly foundation, particularly on 5 August 2022 and 12 August 2022.”

Worse than anticipated

Sadly, issues modified.

Desai stated within the letter that the “earliest provisional outcomes of my crew’s investigation of the monetary place” of Constantia Insurance coverage urged its monetary place was worse than anticipated.

“As communicated to the authority on the time, I had authentic considerations relating to unqualified reliance on these outcomes on condition that, amongst different issues, I solely had entry to unaudited information; the outcomes had not but been examined with the corporate’s head of actuarial perform; and I had not but acquired a proof of the corporate’s therapy of the relevant solvency quota share preparations.

“The accessible information procured by me from the corporate’s head of actuarial perform report a markedly worse monetary place, as contained in my report back to you dated 12 August 2022,” wrote Desai, including that Constantia then wanted a solvency capital requirement of roughly R909 million, however that the solvency capital requirement ratio on the time was zero.

“Whereas now we have not had the chance to interrogate the valuation of the corporate’s unlisted funding portfolio, now we have fashioned the view that there’s a low probability of full restoration of associated get together mortgage belongings and have noticed additional deterioration of the illiquid listed fairness portfolio since 30 June 2022.

“My projections at this stage point out that the enterprise is unlikely to have enough money movement to allow it to function till the return day of the court docket order.

“The corporate doesn’t have any real looking choices to borrow to fund its inevitable money shortfall,” stated Desai.

He famous that Constantia Insurance coverage’s government administration – suspended on the time – didn’t dispute his evaluation of the stability sheet, regardless of having been afforded a possibility to appropriate or complement his views.


Desai then concluded that there was no advantage in in search of to put in writing new insurance policies and to take action would have uncovered new and current policyholders.

“I’ve been unable to influence any previously tentative buyers to decide to recapitalise the corporate and (the deteriorated monetary place) has made it unattainable to draw any further potential buyers, with the end result that efforts to preserve the enterprise aren’t possible.

“The corporate has no prospects of reaching compliance with part 36 of the Insurance coverage Act within the foreseeable future, if in any respect,” he stated, then recommending that Constantia Insurance coverage needs to be liquidated.

Liquidation implies that policyholders with legitimate claims towards their insurer grow to be claimants within the liquidation course of, and settlement of claims is successfully suspended.

“A industrial consequence is that any run-off liabilities that stay with the corporate won’t be lined by enough belongings given the bancrupt place of the corporate. In my capability as provisional curator, there’s nothing that may be performed to arrest this course of, which in the end serves to probably prejudice present policyholders,” stated Desai.

He proposed that the FSCA waive the same old requirement of 30 days’ discover to cancel insurance policies to permit purchasers to instantly search new insurance coverage, and really useful another help or intervention that the FSCA may give to assist these policyholders.

On 14 September 2022, the Gauteng Division of the Excessive Court docket granted an order to position Constantia Insurance coverage underneath remaining liquidation.

Pending claims

The FSCA notes in its current announcement that it’s conscious and anxious that sure Constantia Insurance coverage policyholders with legitimate motorized vehicle claims are experiencing challenges with securing the discharge of their automobiles from service suppliers, equivalent to panel beaters and restore retailers, as a consequence of non-payment of claims.

In brief, policyholders with claims might want to pay for repairs themselves, and be part of the queue of collectors making an attempt to get one thing from the stays of Constantia Insurance coverage.

“The processing of and fee of current claims will likely be adversely affected by the insolvency proceedings, however the liquidators will advise all current claimants quickly on the steps they should take as a part of the insolvency proceedings to submit and show their claims as a part of the insolvency course of.

“All of the CICL’s unpaid claims will likely be thought-about in the end by the liquidators as a part of the winding up course of. As soon as the liquidators have thought-about and brought a view on the corporate potential to make funds (in complete or partially) of the present claims, this will likely be communicated to all current claimants,” says the Prudential Authority.

The FSCA says that the liquidation may also lead to pointless storage prices for policyholders.

“The FSCA urges service suppliers to instantly launch automobiles if no repairs have been made or to permit claimants to settle funds on to safe the discharge of their automobiles.”