Finest and worst automotive insurance coverage corporations within the UK 2023

How do I discover the perfect automotive insurance coverage?

Automobile insurance coverage may be costly, however you do not have to sacrifice nice cowl simply to get the most affordable worth.

Which? can assist you discover the perfect automotive insurance coverage suppliers and insurance policies. Not solely will we price 78 parts of a automotive insurance coverage coverage, we additionally ask hundreds of actual clients who’ve claimed how they price their insurer, together with names resembling LV, Direct Line and Churchill. From customer support and worth to extra and ease making a declare, our surveys ask in-depth questions on an important elements of taking out a automotive insurance coverage coverage.

Along with utilizing our opinions, you may as well get monetary savings in your automotive insurance coverage coverage with a couple of easy methods:

Finest and worst UK automotive insurance coverage corporations

Our buyer surveys and coverage evaluation is used to rank automotive insurance coverage suppliers. The highest scoring suppliers may be named a Which? Advisable Supplier (WRP) if they will meet the next situations. They need to:

  • Be regulated by the Monetary Conduct Authority (FCA)
  • Be out there to most people
  • Have obtained responses from 30 or extra clients in our survey
  • Obtain excessive scores in our buyer satisfaction survey
  • Obtain a mean or above coverage rating.

As well as, we cannot award a supplier our WRP endorsement if they’ve a poorer than common claims rating.

The primary listing compares solely these automotive insurers we have been in a position to price for each insurance policies and buyer expertise. It is ordered by complete rating.

The second listing compares automotive insurance coverage insurance policies – an insurer might provide a couple of.

Automobile insurers with coverage and buyer scores

Desk final up to date in February 2023. Subsequent replace in February 2024.

Which automotive insurers are Advisable Suppliers?


LV was greatest rated by claimants in our survey, scoring 79%, and its coverage was the very best scoring (77%) when put next towards different automotive insurance coverage suppliers’ commonplace insurance policies. It is one among a minority of suppliers guaranteeing repairs for a automobile’s lifetime, and one among simply 11 providing the policyholder a brief alternative automotive if theirs is stolen.

It additionally stands out by providing safety for no-claims bonuses towards a vast variety of claims.

Clients in our survey gave LV reward for its capability to take care of queries and provide worth for cash. Some 35% of LV claimants in our survey felt they have been getting a less expensive worth with it than what was on provide from different insurers – a sentiment shared by 26% of claimants total.

NFU Mutual

NFU Mutual holds the singular honour of by no means having misplaced its WRP standing since we launched the scheme greater than a decade in the past. It did persistently properly in our evaluation this 12 months – simply behind LV each for its buyer rating (78%) and coverage rating (76%) – reaching second place total.

It is one among simply two suppliers we reviewed that does not cost a cancellation charge, or curiosity if you wish to pay month-to-month. 

You will not discover NFU Mutual on comparability websites. You may get a quote by calling one among its 300 branches.

Sadly NFU Mutual might not provide a coverage to clients in all postcodes, significantly main cities.

  • Discover out extra: what will we consider NFU Mutual’s residence insurance coverage coverage?

Direct Line

One of many largest insurers available in the market, Direct Line retains its place as a Which? Advisable Supplier.

It achieved a buyer rating of 78% – joint second with NFU Mutual.

In contrast to its sister manufacturers Churchill and Privilege, Direct Line would not seem on worth comparability websites, however it’s properly value contacting them or visiting their web site to get a quote.


Churchill  obtained the third-highest buyer rating (75%) this 12 months. Its commonplace coverage had a slightly-above-average rating (of 66%) in our evaluation. 

Like its sister model, Direct Line, we appreciated its fairer strategy to clients’ no-claims low cost. For instance, it will not hack on the reductions of those that have claimed as a result of their automotive was vandalised.  


Aviva is our fifth WRP – with a robust buyer rating of 74% (putting it sixth of 15 manufacturers). Its commonplace coverage merited a good 66% in our evaluation. 

The insurer sells barely completely different variants of its cowl by comparability websites – referred to as ‘Aviva On-line’ (scoring 65%) and ‘Aviva Premium’ (66%). Aviva has greater than 18 million clients because of insurance policies resembling courtesy automotive inclusion and unintentional harm cowl.

  • Discover out extra: Automobile insurance coverage for the over 50s

How we discover the perfect automotive insurers

Buyer scores

The shopper rating relies on a survey of two,454 policyholders who’ve lately made a automotive insurance coverage declare. The rating displays how glad clients say they’re with their supplier and the way seemingly they’d be to advocate it.

Suppliers should obtain a minimal pattern dimension of 30 to be included.

Why solely discuss to clients who’ve claimed?

You may solely understand how good an insurer’s customer support actually is when it’s important to make a declare.

That is when good insurers will present their capability to take care of issues, rapidly course of your declare and get you again on the street as quickly as attainable.

As it may be troublesome to search out the requisite variety of clients who’ve claimed for some insurers, in some circumstances we’re solely in a position to present our knowledgeable coverage scores.

Coverage scores

The coverage rating is our evaluation of the standard of normal cowl evaluating 78 parts of a automotive insurance coverage coverage. We weight sure options of canopy or prices (charges and excesses) based mostly on the impression we expect they typically make, from courtesy automobiles to breakdown cowl.

Among the many highest-weighted parts are the insurer’s assure on repairs, cowl for glass harm, situations of its no-claims low cost, whether or not it will present a alternative automobile, its fireplace, theft and unintentional harm excesses, and rates of interest charged for paying premiums in instalments.

We supply this evaluation out each 12 months. The subsequent replace might be in February 2024.

Whole rating

The place buyer and coverage scores can be found, insurance coverage suppliers are ranked by their complete rating. This rating is made up of fifty% of the client rating, and 50% of the automotive insurance coverage coverage rating.

Getting an affordable automotive insurance coverage deal may be difficult, however we’ve partnered with that will help you evaluate insurance policies and purchase insurance coverage from one among their 100+ suppliers.

Does automotive insurance coverage mechanically renew?

Sure. If you take out a automotive insurance coverage coverage it’s commonplace on your settlement to auto-renew after 12 months. 

Your supplier will let between 21 and 30 days prior that your coverage is up for renewal, and in the event you take no motion it’s going to auto-renew with the identical particulars together with extra, no-claims bonus, add-ons, charges and fees

Some insurance policies have a 10-month possibility, so you will need to double verify your settlement to see what number of months till your auto-renew kicks in. Sticking along with your present coverage will not be the best choice for you. Discover out why you should not permit your coverage to auto-renew.

Can automotive insurance coverage be transferred to a brand new automotive?

Sure. Your automotive insurance coverage coverage may be transferred to your new automotive even in case you are halfway by your 12-month coverage. As soon as the switch is full, your new automotive might be coated in the identical method as your earlier mannequin. 

Some insurance coverage suppliers will cost an admin charge to alter your particulars. These modifications ought to embody your automotive make, mannequin and mileage. You will need to keep in mind that your new automotive might have an effect in your automotive insurance coverage premiums.

Your insurance coverage supplier might want to know the date to modify over the insurance policies. The most effective time to contact them is as soon as when you find yourself gathering your new automotive from the dealership or vendor. This manner, you possibly can accumulate your automotive and drive it residence that day along with your new insurance coverage utilized. 

This text delivers free money-related content material, together with different details about Which? Group services and products. Unsubscribe everytime you need. Your knowledge might be processed in accordance with our Privateness coverage

What varieties of automotive insurance coverage are there?

The principle three varieties of commonplace automotive insurance coverage are third celebration, third celebration fireplace and theft, and complete.

Third celebration is essentially the most primary stage of canopy and is the authorized minimal. It covers harm you trigger to different drivers on the street, however not harm to your personal automobile.

Third celebration, fireplace and theft is the following band of insurance coverage up. This additionally pays out in case your automotive is stolen, vandalised or severely broken. 

Complete automotive insurance coverage affords the widest protection for you and your automotive. It’ll cowl each you, your automotive, the opposite driver and their automotive in an accident.

Inside these classes there are specialist varieties of coverage together with traditional automotive, multi-car and learner driver automotive insurance coverage

How a lot is the common month-to-month price of automotive insurance coverage?

As of February 2023, the common automotive insurance coverage premium paid by drivers was £470, in line with the Affiliation of British Insurers.

This was 8% greater than within the earlier quarter, with insurers blaming rising restore prices.

The typical paid for brand new insurance policies was £531 and the common for renewing a coverage was £428. Keep in mind your extra, automotive mannequin kind and your age can enhance your automotive insurance coverage premiums. 

How can I get low cost automotive insurance coverage?

From haggling along with your supplier to utilizing comparability websites, there are a variety of how you possibly can discover low cost automotive insurance coverage. You will need to store round and do your analysis to achieve a robust understanding of what a aggressive worth appears like earlier than making a call. 

Insurance coverage corporations are not allowed to supply higher offers to new clients, so it’s in your greatest curiosity to search out out what your present supplier is keen to give you in addition to testing the perfect offers on worth comparability websites. 

It’s value noting that Direct Line automotive insurance coverage is barely out there instantly and NFU Mutual will not be on-line in any respect, you have to name them as much as talk about their insurance policies.

Obtained extra questions on automotive insurance coverage? Check out our guides:

Supply By coverage/car-insurance/car-insurance/best-and-worst-car-insurance-a3PuA5f3sB6q